女生小视频

Life

David Attenborough's Our Planet on Netflix is beautiful but empty

The veteran naturalist lays the blame for Earth鈥檚 increasingly fragile ecosystem on humans, yet the stunning visuals in Netflix鈥檚 Our Planet聽add little to the genre

By Adam Vaughan

4 April 2019

New 女生小视频. Science news and long reads from expert journalists, covering developments in science, technology, health and the environment on the website and the magazine.

Ben Macdonald / Silverback/Netflix

A聽young Philippine eagle sits atop the rainforest canopy, noisily badgering its mother for food. 鈥淭he chick is very demanding,鈥 says David Attenborough, wryly. But the bird is soon fending for itself, risking death as it flaps precariously along a branch 70聽metres high. Finally, we are treated to the soaring sight of its first flight or, as Attenborough puts it, the day when 鈥渃onfidence suddenly matches know-how鈥.

Our Planet, Netflix鈥檚 flagship nature series, is classic wildlife TV,聽with sumptuous visuals and engaging narratives. But what makes it interesting is another strand, where satellite images document the rapid loss of rainforest in the Philippines and聽Borneo in recent decades. The聽young eagle survived its first flight, but there is barely enough habitat left for such a super-sized bird of prey to flourish.

Fragility is the link: how wildlife and ecosystems fare in聽the face of human pressure, something primetime nature series have only recently begun to touch on. 鈥淭he stability of nature can no longer be taken for granted,鈥 says Attenborough in the first of the eight episodes.

New 女生小视频. Science news and long reads from expert journalists, covering developments in science, technology, health and the environment on the website and the magazine.

Huw Cordey/Silverback/Netflix

The threats to the planet are legion, and the series duly covers everything from the disruption of the weather systems that animals and plants rely on to poaching and deforestation, Arctic sea ice loss and ocean acidification.

It is also rich with wonders. There is New Guinea鈥檚 twelve-wired bird of paradise, which uses its wire-like filaments to tickle the face of a potential mate. And there is a great montage of tropical forest ants killed by fungi that turn them into zombies. 鈥淏ut,鈥 says Attenborough (and there are a lot of buts in Our Planet), 鈥渢he diversity of the world鈥檚 rainforests is falling at an alarming rate, and that is because of us.鈥

The series brings home the consequences for us too, from the聽role forests play in regulating Earth鈥檚 climate, to the foods and medicines they furnish us with. Frustratingly, though, the role of聽the viewer is unexplored, which聽leads to an odd feeling of disconnect. We see the contrast between monocultures of palm oil plantations and the richness of聽primary forests. Attenborough warns that the result is the young orangutans we see could be the last generation in the wild. But the show stops short of blaming our demand for the myriad products we buy that contain palm oil.

New 女生小视频. Science news and long reads from expert journalists, covering developments in science, technology, health and the environment on the website and the magazine.

fishing boat : Gisle Sverdrup/Silverback/Netflix

Similarly, the effects of climate change feature throughout, but the dots are never fully joined to expose humans at the heart of the聽pressure. The 鈥渇rightening pace鈥 of change in the Arctic is examined, from loss of sea ice to spectacular footage of glaciers calving and a huge stretch of Greenland ice breaking away. The聽carbon emissions, fossil fuel聽companies and human consumption behind such rapid changes, however, are absent.

The degradation of habitats created by humans is mostly off-screen, too, with a few exceptions, such as a bleached coral reef.

This aside, there is plenty to like聽in Our Planet. The diversity of聽locations and whirlwind tour of聽the globe puts many a Bond film to shame, and the production is lavish, with a score by turns elegiac, comic and stirring.

There are stunning shots, from long, tracking scenes of big cats hunting, to close-ups of abseiling caterpillars and deep sea worms鈥 jaws emerging to bite urchins. Haunting footage of wolves and forests in the areas around the site聽of the Chernobyl nuclear disaster illustrate nature鈥檚 ability to rebound.

New 女生小视频. Science news and long reads from expert journalists, covering developments in science, technology, health and the environment on the website and the magazine.

Description:Attenborough : Keith Scoley/Silverback/Netflix

At 92, Attenborough remains a master broadcaster, as at home narrating the light relief of dancing birds of prey as he is explaining our unsustainable fishing practices. Kids will love it.

Ultimately, though, it is unclear what Our Planet adds to the genre. Most of the species it shows have been covered extensively before, and there is no deep delving into any particular habitat, as in Frozen Planet, or detailed coverage of a species, as in Dynasties.

For a show meant to shine a light on 鈥渙ur鈥 impact on nature, people and our responsibility are rarer than the desert elephants and bluefin tuna the show so beautifully depicts.


 

, Netflix, from Friday 5 April 2019

Topics:

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with New 女生小视频 events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop